Plum Island Beachcoma Dining Menu

Full Menu Thursday-Sunday
Specialty menu Wednesday


Cathy's Buffalo Chicken Dip


Back by Popular Demand! Served Hot with Crispy Tortilla Chips.

‘Coma Nachos


Tortilla Chips Topped With Shredded Sharp Cheddar Cheese Topped With House Pico, Sour Cream & Fresh Jalapenos - Add Chicken $7, Brisket $7, Chili $5

Edamame Bowl


Steamed & Tossed in Sea Salt

Chicken Tenders


House Brined & Fried . Choose your style: Sweet Baby Rays BBQ, Buffalo, Caribbean Jerk Dusted or Sweet & Sticky. Extra side sauce $.50

Wings (8)


8 pieces, Sweet Baby Rays BBQ, Buffalo, Caribbean Jerk Dusted or Sweet & Sticky » extra side sauce $.50

Pretzel Bites (8)


8 Bites with Grained-Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce

Soup & Salad

Plum Island Clam Chowder


Served Piping Hot With The Perfect amount of Cracked Black Pepper.

Boss's Crock of Chili


Topped with Cheese & Served with Tortilla Chips

Caesar Salad*


House Caesar Dressing, Romaine, Parmesan & Croutons - Add Grilled or Fried Chicken $7, Salmon $9

Fall Winter Classic Salad


Mixed Greens, Roasted Butternut Squash, Goat Cheese, Pumpkin Seeds, Sliced Red Onion, Craisins tossed in a Apple Cider Vinaigrette - Add Grilled or Fried Chicken $7, Salmon $9


Two Flour Tortillas served with French Fries or Cole Slaw.
Add Third Taco $5. Upgrade to Sweet Fries $3, Demi Caesar Salad $5
Corn Tortilla available upon request. 

Crispy Pork Belly


Two tacos with Pico, Citrus Slaw, Garlic Mayo - 3rd taco $5



Two tacos, Blackened or Fried with Citrus Slaw, Pico, Chipotle Ranch - 3rd taco $5

Blackened Salmon


Two tacos with Pico, Citrus Slaw, Mango Habanero Sauce - 3rd taco $5

Fried Chicken Taco


Two tacos with Citrus Slaw, Pico, Chipotle Ranch - 3rd taco $5

Hand Helds

Sandwiches served with French Fries or Cole Slaw and Pickle Spear.
Gluten Free Bun … $2
Upgrade to Sweet Fries … $3, or Demi Caesar Salad … $5

Roast Beef French Dip


Horseradish Mayo, Toasted Italian Loaf, Gouda Cheese. - Served with a Thickened Au Jus for dipping.

Smash Burger


Ground Chuck Served Medium Well, Garlic Aioli, Shredded Romaine, B&B Pickles, Red Onion, American Cheese. - Add Bacon $2, Extra Patty $6

Smoked Brisket Quesadilla


Stuffed with Pico, Cheddar Cheese, Flour tortilla. - Side of Sour Cream on side .

Ultimate Grilled Cheese


Gouda, Havarti and American Cheese with Grilled Tomato & Bacon on Crispy Brioche Bread

Chicken Sandwich - Grilled or Fried


B&B Pickles, Buttermilk Ranch, Pepperjack, Bacon - Make it Buffalo $1


Fish N’ Chips


Fried Haddock Fillet, French Fries, Cole Slaw, Lemon, Tartar Sauce

Big Kid Chicken Tenders


8 Tenders Served with French Fries, Cole Slaw


Buffalo Chicken Pizza


Chicken Caesar Pizza


Plain Cheese


Add Peppers, Onion or Jalapenos, $1.50. Pepperoni, Sliced Sausage, Crumbled Bacon, $2.

Add-ons: Sauteed Peppers, Onion or Jalapenos … $1.50
Pepperoni, Sliced Sausage, Crumbled Bacon … $2.00

Entrées - After 5pm

Baked Haddock


Haddock, Light Crumb Topping with a Lemon Caper Sauce served with Mashed Potatoes and Veg of the Day

Blackened Chicken Pasta


Blackened Chicken, Sweet Peas, Prosciutto in a Creamy Parmesan Sauce

Slow Braised Short Rib


Country Style (celery, carrots, onions) Slow Braised Short Ribs served over Mashed Potatoes


Double Chocolate Molten Lava Cake a la mode


Come on, you know you want it!

Fried Dough Bites


Powdered Sugar and Drizzled with Chocolate Sauce - Add Vanilla Ice Cream $3.

Apple Crisp Ala Mode


Homemade Apple Crisp served warm with a scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream. - Drunken Version topped with Apple Pie Moonshine add $2

Allergens & Tips

While our kitchen is Gluten Sensitive, we do not have a designated gluten-free kitchen.

Please advise your server of allergies.

Consuming raw or undercook meats, shellfish or eggs may be harmful to your health.

18% gratuity added to parties of 8 or more.